The premier weekly newspaper for the legal profession in Ontario
Issue link: https://read.uberflip.com/i/223044
Sponsored content What is Elder Law? By Kimberly Whaley, Whaley Estate Litiation T he answer to this question is fluid. It can look like any legal issue involving an older adult. Elder abuse can be prevalent in any practice. It can be sexual, emotional or financial in nature or even neglect. It usually involves an abuse of trust where the adult is dependant, vulnerable or susceptible to undue influence yet not necessarily compromised as to decisional capacity. According to the Federal Department of Justice, financial exploitation is tremendously underreported. Our population is aging rapidly. Our society is made up of complex family structures influenced by advances in technology and communications. Globally, we are facing the largest demographic shift in history. Abuse can be perpetrated by any number of vehicles: fraudulent procurement or use of a power of attorney document, securing a joint account or tenancy, targeted financial scams and more. The Substitute Decisions Act legislation provides a legal process for issues related to decisional incapacity or vulnerability. It offers a framework for determining capacity and for the implementation of substitute decision-making. Our legal frameworks are not perfect, not Untitled-3 1 having been legislated at a time when current societal issues were prevalent. As such, we are seeing civil remedies being morphed into claims seeking to employ an appropriate result. We are learning through court decisions, the legal limitations faced. The case of, Juzumas v. Baron involved a common scenario: An older adult influenced by an unscrupulous, substantially younger caretaker, who moved to fulfil more of the latter part of that verb. The plaintiff, 89 years old with limited English was befriended and promised care so as to avoid the consequence he most feared: moving to a nursing home. Ultimately, she convinced him to marry, qualifying for his pension on death. The day before their wedding, a Will in contemplation of marriage was executed. Notably, the lawyer did not meet the plaintiff alone. The plaintiff's house was transferred. The Judge found that even if the transfer agreement had been shown to the plaintiff, his English would not have sufficed to enable him to understand it. The Judge found that he was "acceding to someone else's direction" and not a wilful and active participant to the transaction. The Judge considered a "cluster of remedies…where a stronger party takes advantage of a weaker party in the course of inducing the weaker party's consent" and outlined the legal doctrines of undue influence, and unconscionability. Deciding ultimately that the presumption of undue influence existed between the parties, the relationship was not one of equals, and the doctrine of unconscionability armed the court with the jurisdiction to set aside the agreements, the court did so and granted a divorce. This case is insightful and somewhat of a rarity; unusual, because the victim possessed decisional capacity to right the wrong, whereas often the victim is incapable of righting the wrong. Importantly, our Criminal Code assists, in that it provides for the following charges: theft by a person holding a power of attorney (s. 331); theft (s. 322); criminal breach of trust (conversion by trustee) (s. 336); forgery (s. 366,); extortion (s. 346); fraud (ss. 386-388); neglect; failure to provide the necessities of life (s. 215); and criminal negligence (s. 219). The recently enacted Protection of Older Adults Act expands the list of aggravating factors against victims "who are vulnerable due to age and other personal circumstances." Elder law is and will be a growth area. An approach to legal remedies in this area may include both civil and criminal considerations as well as a practical strategy. 13-11-20 8:48 AM

