Law Times - Newsmakers

2013 Top Newsmakers

The premier weekly newspaper for the legal profession in Ontario

Issue link: https://read.uberflip.com/i/223044

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 5 of 15

top newsmakers Court at the end of August, Prime Minister Stephen Harper tapped Nadon to replace him. While Nadon's Oct. 3 appointment would maintain the necessary roster of three Quebec judges, there has been quite a bit of controversy over the selection process. Toronto lawyer Rocco Galati, along with the Constitutional Rights Centre Inc., filed a court challenge on Oct. 8 to Nadon's appointment. He argued that as a Federal Court judge, the Supreme Court Act precludes Nadon's appointment to the top court. Justice Marc Nadon Nadon a controversial appointment to Canada's top court Wrangling over Justice Marc Nadon's appointment has left the Supreme Court short one member By Heather Gardiner With several Supreme Court of Canada judges reaching the mandatory retirement age of 75 in recent years, vacancies have been opening up on the bench. But it's not always easy to fill them, as the appointment of Justice Marc Nadon has shown. Following justice Morris Fish's retirement from the Supreme "If an individual has 'at least ten years standing at the bar of a province' he or she 'is or has been' such a member, and despite a lapse of time while serving the Federal Court, the s. 5 requirement is met." When properly interpreted, ss. 5 and 6 of the Supreme Court Act allow only for the appointment of Quebec Court of Appeal or Superior Court judges or, alternatively, a lawyer who has been a member of the Quebec bar for at least 10 years, Galati argues. Galati says Nadon, as a Federal Court of Appeal judge, doesn't fit that criteria. The Quebec government is also challenging the legality of Nadon's appointment. Prior to Nadon's nomination, Harper had sought a legal opinion from former Supreme Court justice Ian Binnie on the matter. According to Binnie, "there is nothing in the Supreme Court of Canada Act" that would prevent the appointment. "In the English version, the words 'is or has been' refer grammatically to both judges and advocates," said Binnie. "If an individual has 'at least ten years standing at the bar of a province' he or she 'is or has been' such a member, and despite a lapse of time while serving the Federal Court, the s. 5 requirement is met." But Galati disputes Binnie's opinion, arguing there are different provisions that apply to Quebec judges. "We feel that the issue should not have been the subject of an opinion of a retired What do your clients need? The means to move on. Guaranteed.™ Contact us at 1 800 387 1686 or baxterstructures.com Kyla A. Baxter, CSSC PRESIDENT, BAXTER STRUCTURES 6 December 2013 Untitled-4 1 13-11-18 7:09 PM

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of Law Times - Newsmakers - 2013 Top Newsmakers