The premier weekly newspaper for the legal profession in Ontario
Issue link: https://read.uberflip.com/i/96768
top stories Articling issue comes to a head Diverging visions on offer as LSUC revamps licensing system By HEATHER GARDINER W the majority's proposal. Instead, it would like ith Ontario's articling crisis to abolish articling and implement a two- to deepening, the Law Society three-month comprehensive transitional of Upper Canada took major training program that would consist of onsteps to address it this year beline learning and exams to assess the core fore making a final decision on Nov. 22. competencies lawyers need to have. The LSUC's articling task force first released Members of the minority expressed conits consultation report to Convocation on Dec. cerns about inequality under a law practice 9, 2011. It proposed five options for the provprogram. ince's licensing process: "We don't like the idea of having what is es• The status quo. sentially a two-tiered system," said Wardle, a • The status quo with quality-assurance impartner at Wardle Daley Bernstein LLP. provements. "In our view, it is inevitable that the LPP • The replacement of a pre-licensing transigraduates will be stigmatized by the profession tion requirement with a post-licensing tranon the basis that these are the candidates who sition requirement. couldn't find articles and therefore are some• A choice of either articling or a practical lehow less qualified," the minority stated in the gal training course. 'We don't like the idea of having what is report. • Only a practical legal training course. essentially a two-tiered system,' says PeAt Convocation on Oct. 25, Horvat echoed After holding public consultations across ter Wardle. that sentiment. the province and considering a plethora of writ"The first question every one of us will ask ten submissions, the task force released its final of a new lawyer who comes to us looking for a job is where did you report on Oct. 16. However, the report included dissenting views from some article," she said. "In our view, no one should be consigned to a second-class stamembers. The majority recommended a five-year pilot project, to begin in tus by a licensing process." But Bencher Wendy Matheson, a member of the task force ma2014, for a law practice program as an alternative option to the current articling system. It suggested the alternative would provide a jority, dismissed fears about a two-tier system. "The proposal is to study two pathways to licensing and to evalway for unplaced candidates to gain the necessary practical skills. The law practice program, to be delivered by one or more third- uate and compare them," she said. "As soon as you study more than party providers, would combine a skills-training component and a one pathway, whatever you do will be described as two-tier." Along with the concern about stigmatization is the issue of cost. co-op work placement for a total of eight months. Under the new system, licensing candidates would still have the The majority recommends spreading the costs of the law practice program among all licensing candidates. option to article. "We had to consider that [LPP] candidates would be paying for The majority also called for a final assessment for all candidates, regardless of the option they choose, to test their practical skills be- the course instead of being paid by an articling principal and that their co-op placement could very well be unpaid as well," said Tom fore receiving their licences. One thing the entire 13-bencher task force did agree on is that Conway, task force chairman and LSUC treasurer. "So from a fairness perspective, the majority came to the concluthe status quo can't continue. It's common knowledge that there aren't enough articling po- sion that that cost should be borne by all licensing candidates across sitions available for all licensing candidates. In its report, the task the board." The majority estimates this would increase the current licensing force acknowledged that as of March 2012, approximately 15 per fee to approximately $5,670 per candidate from $2,950 after factorcent of all candidates were unable to secure articling positions. The minority — consisting of benchers Jacqueline Horvat, ing in a final assessment. Benchers approved the law pratice program on Nov. 22. Vern Krishna, Paul Schabas, and Peter Wardle — disagreed with 2012 top news, newsmakers, and cases 11

