The premier weekly newspaper for the legal profession in Ontario
Issue link: https://read.uberflip.com/i/96768
top cases top cases Privacy, prostitution, copyright among headline-grabbing cases in 2012 By JENNIFER BROWN A number of high-profile cases took centre stage in 2012 and significantly updated the law of the land in several areas. After years of legal wrangling, the Court of Appeal for Ontario ruled it would be legal for prostitutes to work in organized brothels but exploitation by pimps would still be illegal. Employment lawyers were left with questions and concerns when a new tort of intrusion upon seclusion raised the issue of what would be considered an invasion of privacy in the workplace following the decision in Jones v. Tsige. After much debate and discussion in the music, telecommunications, and academic worlds, the Supreme Court ruled on a series of copyright cases that addressed how technology has changed the way we use reading materials and access media and music online. As the plaintiff bar becomes more active in Canada, actions continue to become more complex with two different decisions that created consternation for the class action bar when it came to dealing with certification limits. Later in the year, many were wondering if non-disclosure of HIV status may still be unclear even after the Supreme Court rulings that attempted to clarify its 1998 decision in R. v. Cuerrier. The Ontario Superior Court had dismissed Jones' claim because there was no law in Ontario that recognized a tort of invasion of privacy prior to the Court of Appeal's ruling. The court did set restrictions on the extent of the new tort. "The key features of this cause of action are, first, that the defendant's conduct must be intentional, within which I would include reckless; second that the defendant must have invaded, without lawful justification, the plaintiff 's private affairs or concerns; and third, that a reasonable person would regard the invasion as highly offensive causing distress, humiliation or anguish," Justice Robert Sharpe wrote in the ruling. Outlining another limitation, Sharpe wrote: "A claim for intrusion upon seclusion will arise only for deliberate and significant invasions of personal privacy . . . it is only intrusions into matters such as one's financial or health records, sexual practices and orientation, employment, diary or private correspondence that, viewed objectively on the reasonable person standard, can be described as highly offensive." The court placed a $20,000 limit on the damages to be awarded to any individual under the new tort. Jones was awarded $10,000. uuuJones v. Tsige In a landmark ruling, the Ontario Court of Appeal did away with some of Canada's anti-prostitution laws after concluding the existing system made it difficult for prostitutes to protect themselves. In Canada (Attorney General) v. Bedford, the court changed the definition of a common bawdy house and altered the Criminal Code provision related to living off the avails of prostitution. The appeal court has modernized the law in order to allow sextrade workers to protect themselves by hiring bodyguards and working indoors in bawdy houses. However, soliciting customers The Ontario Court of Appeal recognized a privacy tort of intrusion upon seclusion in a decision that sparked debate about what could be included under that category in the future. In Jones v. Tsige, Sandra Jones and Winnie Tsige worked at different branches of the Bank of Montreal but didn't know each other. Tsige began a relationship with Jones' former husband and over a period of four years, Tsige accessed Jones' personal bank accounts 174 times. Jones sued Tsige for invasion of privacy and sought $20,000 in damages. 8 December 2012 uuuCanada (Attorney General) v. Bedford

