top cases
on the street remains illegal. The Supreme Court of Canada has
agreed to hear an appeal of the ruling.
uuuFive copyright decisions from the SCC
In July, the Supreme Court of Canada handed down its decisions in
five copyright cases that in effect scrapped some existing copyright
fees and clarified copyright rules for the Internet.
The Copyright Board had approved taxes for downloading but
they were appealed by large Canadian telecommunications companies like Rogers Communications Inc., Bell Canada, Telus Communications Co., and Shaw Cablesystems GP.
In Entertainment Software Association v. Society of Composers,
Authors, and Music Publishers of Canada and Rogers Communications Inc. v. Society of Composers, Authors, and Music Publishers of
Canada, the top court was tasked with determining what qualifies
as a communication to the public.
In Rogers, the court found that on-demand services have to pay
for uses of music. Rogers argued it could have on-demand services
like pay-per-view for free, which wasn't considered communicating
to the public.
On behalf of the majority in Rogers, Justice Marshall Rothstein
wrote: "In these circumstances, the transmission of any file containing a musical work, starting with the first, from the online service's
web site to the customer's computer, at the customer's request, constitutes 'communicat[ing]' the work to the public by telecommunication."
In Entertainment Software Association, the court found that a
download wasn't a communication to the public.
In Society of Composers, Authors, and Music Publishers of Canada
v. Bell Canada, the court determined that music previews are considered fair dealing. As such, previews on services such as iTunes,
for instance, don't merit the payment of royalties.
With its ruling in Province of Alberta v. Canadian Copyright
Licensing Agency, which involved a dispute over copyright rules
for photocopying textbooks at schools, the top court clarified the
framework for fair dealing. Under fair dealing, there have to be two
steps: the first to see if it's an allowable purpose and the second to
see if the dealing is fair.
uuuSilver v. Imax and Sharma v. Timminco
Imax Corp.'s summary judgment motion based on a limitation
defence was denied in late August, giving the class action bar
cause for celebration in light of other decisions that seemed to go
against plaintiffs in similar circumstances where lengthy proceedings delayed matters.
In Silver v. Imax, Superior Court Justice Katherine van Rensburg dismissed Imax' motion for summary judgment seeking to
dismiss the statutory claims of the plaintiffs for secondary-market
misrepresentation.
In her decision, van Rensburg wrote: "No public interest would
be served by permitting a cause of action to be defeated by delays
inherent in the litigation process. As argued by the plaintiffs in NorDor, '[the expiry of a limitation period while the leave motion is
pending] cannot have been the intention of the legislature when it
enacted this section of the act.'"
A month before that, plaintiffs in a secondary-markets securities class action case involving CIBC were denied certification even
though Ontario Superior Court Justice George Strathy indicated he
saw merit in the case.
On July 3, Strathy ruled in Green v. Canadian Imperial Bank
of Commerce that the plaintiffs had failed to obtain the required
leave to proceed with the action within the three-year period
mandated by the Ontario Securities Act. The plaintiffs' request to
certify common law claims for negligent misrepresentation was
also rejected.
Strathy relied on Sharma v. Timminco Ltd. in rendering his decision in the CIBC case. The Court of Appeal in Sharma v. Timminco
confirmed that plaintiffs pursuing claims for statutory misrepresentation on the secondary market must complete the leave motion, obtain leave, and issue a claim within three years of the alleged
misrepresentation.
uuuR. v. Mabior and R. v. D.C.
On Oct. 5, the Supreme Court of Canada ruled that some people
with low levels of HIV who use condoms during sex don't need to
disclose their condition to sexual partners.
In a 9-0 ruling, the top court updated a 1998 decision in R. v. Cuerrier that made it a crime if HIV carriers didn't reveal their status
when there was a significant risk of transmission to a sexual partner.
This time, the court ruled that the "realistic possibility of transmission of HIV is negated" provided the carrier of the virus has
a low viral load and a condom is used during sexual intercourse.
Otherwise, HIV carriers have to disclose their status to their partners.
Critics say the Supreme Court rulings could lead to a spike in
non-disclosure prosecutions.
E. V. Litigation & Financial Services Inc.
Elaine G. Vegotsky, CMA, CFE, CFI
Assisting you in
Litigation & Forensic Accounting, Financial Investigations
Suite 900
45 Sheppard Avenue East,
Willowdale, Ontario M2N 5W9
EV-Litigation_LT_Splmnt_11.indd 1
Telephone (416) 930-1370
and/or Fax (905) 731-5812
evlitigation@rogers.com
11-11-25 10:02 AM
2012 top news, newsmakers, and cases 9