The premier weekly newspaper for the legal profession in Ontario
Issue link: https://read.uberflip.com/i/223044
Top Cases 2013 Human rights cases, right to die, and Criminal Code penalties levied in construction deaths grab spotlight in 2013 By Jennifer Brown 2013 was a year of several firsts as a number of cases grabbed headlines and changed the course of how the law would view certain longdebated issues. Five years after the province passed amendments allowing employees to piggyback discrimination claims on wrongful dismissal cases claiming a breach of contract in the Superior Court, a decision in Wilson v. Solis Mexican Foods Inc. awarded the first damages under that scenario. In another big decision, the controversial claim in Choc v. HudBay Minerals Inc. received the green light to proceed to trial in Ontario. There was also a landmark decision that saw the fine in a workplace safety case involving four migrant workers who died in 2009 increase substantially from the original amount after a review by the Court of Appeal. And late in the year, the Supreme Court of Canada ruled narrowly in Cuthbertson v. Rasouli that under Ontario's Health Care Consent Act, doctors couldn't end life support unilaterally, although they may do so with the backing of a special panel. 8 December 2013 ONTARIO v. CRIMINAL LAWYERS' ASSOCIATION OF ONTARIO Although the courts have the power to appoint amicus curiae, they can't set their fees, the Supreme Court of Canada decided in August. The court's 5-4 decision in Ontario v. Criminal Lawyers' Association of Ontario relates to four criminal cases in which the trial judges appointed amicus curiae, determined the rate of pay, and then ordered the attorney general to pay the lawyers from public funds. The attorney general argued the courts don't have the authority to set the fees for amicus curiae. The Court of Appeal disagreed, ruling the courts do have the power to appoint amicus curiae as well as set the rate of compensation and monitor the accounts. But the Supreme Court ruled against the Court of Appeal's decision. On behalf of the majority, Justice Andromache Karakatsanis wrote: "Absent statutory authority or a challenge on constitutional grounds, courts do not have the institutional jurisdiction to interfere with the allocation of public funds. "While the jurisdiction to control court processes and function as a court of law gives courts the power to appoint amici curiae, it does not, in itself, provide the power to determine what the attorney general must pay them. The scope of a superior court's inherent power, or of powers possessed by statutory courts by necessary implication, must respect the constitutional roles and institutional capacities of the legislature, the executive, and the judiciary. As the chief law officers of the Crown, responsible for the administration of justice on behalf of the provinces, the attorneys general of the provinces, and not the courts, determine the appropriate rate of compensation for amici curiae." Justice Morris Fish, on behalf of the dissenting minority, argued the courts should be able to set the fees for amicus curiae and that there's "no constitutional impediment" in doing so. CHOC v. HUDBAY MINERALS INC. The Guatemalan workers alleging rape and murder on a property owned by the subsidiary of a Canadian mining company have only had to prove one thing so far: that their case against Hudbay Minerals Inc. wouldn't plainly and obviously fail if it proceeded to trial. So when Superior Court Justice Carole Brown ordered the case in Choc v. HudBay Minerals Inc. to proceed, it shouldn't necessarily have come as a surprise to some people. But for a key reason, it did.

