The premier weekly newspaper for the legal profession in Ontario
Issue link: https://read.uberflip.com/i/223044
top cases Part of the surprise stemmed from the fact Brown's decision meant the case would proceed to trial in Ontario. But the jurisdiction matter was specific to this case and will likely not set a strong precedent. For the corporate world, perhaps the more ominous part of Brown's decision is where she sets out a test for a novel duty of care to the plaintiffs. One of the tests for a duty of care — proximity — could be met in this case, the judge found, after going through a list of communications and actions by the company that suggested they could have been closely related to the complainants. The fact that it's debatable whether the defendants should have a duty of care meant the case deserved a trial, added Brown. R. V. METRON CONSTRUCTION CORP. The Ontario Court of Appeal nearly quadrupled the fine for a construction company involved in the 2009 Christmas Eve scaffolding accident that caused the deaths of four workers. The Ontario Court of Justice had imposed a fine of $200,000 after Metron Construction Corp. pleaded guilty to criminal negligence causing death. But on Sept. 4, the Court of Appeal increased the fine to $750,000 in its ruling in R. v. Metron Construction Corp. The incident occurred when six workers, including the site supervisor, boarded scaffolding to take them from the 14th floor of a building to the ground. The scaffolding was only meant to hold the weight of two people and therefore included just two harnesses. As a result, the scaffolding collapsed and four workers died. The two workers wearing harnesses survived. A toxicology analysis revealed three of the four workers who died, including the site supervisor, had levels of marijuana in their systems indicating they had recently ingested the drug. Writing on behalf of the appeal court bench, Justice Sarah Pepall concluded the fine imposed by the Ontario Court of Justice was too low and that the judge had erred by considering similar penalties under the Occupational Health and Safety Act instead of the stronger sanctions under the Criminal Code. It was the first time the court had criminally convicted an Ontario company for workplace deaths since amendments to the Criminal Code in 2004. WILSON V. SOLIS MEXICAN FOODS INC. A London, Ont., woman was the first to receive human rights damages from the Ontario Superior Court in a wrongful dismissal action under provisions of the Ontario Human Rights Code. In Wilson v. Solis Mexican Foods Inc., the Superior Court relied on the relatively new s. 46.1 to award a human rights remedy in a wrongful dismissal case. In 2008, the amendments allowed employees who bring wrongful dismissal cases claiming a breach of contract to include discrimination claims. Justice Duncan Grace awarded Patricia Wilson $20,000 in damages. A certified general accountant who earned $65,000 a year, Wilson had worked for Solis Mexican Foods for more than 16 months when the company terminated her in May 2011. She received two weeks' pay in lieu of notice. She alleged the company terminated her at least in part because of an ongoing back ailment and that her rights under the Human Rights Code were therefore infringed. CUTHBERTSON V. RASOULI Ontario doctors have no right to unilaterally withdraw life support from a patient if the family objects, the Supreme Court of Canada ruled in October in a case centered on a Toronto man who has been in a coma since 2010. The wife of Hassan Rasouli, a Shiite Muslim, had objected on religious grounds to the doctors' decision to withdraw her husband's life support. She argued that if the doctors could prevent death, they should do so. In Cuthbertson v. Rasouli, the Supreme Court ruled narrowly that under Ontario's Health Care Consent Act, doctors couldn't end life support unilaterally, although they may do so with the backing of a special panel. "While the end-of-life context poses difficult ethical dilemmas for physicians, this does not alter the conclusion that withdrawal of life support constitutes treatment requiring consent under the HCCA," Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin wrote for the 5-2 majority. The health-care consent law allows doctors to ask a provincial board to overrule the wishes of a patient or a substitute decision-maker. The minority opinion of the court said patients don't have the right to remain on life support indefinitely. Putting the legal community front and centre has made us the #1 choice with Canadian lawyers for over a decade. At Stewart Title, we keep real estate transactions where they belong – in your office! The title insurer that puts you front row, centre Untitled-3 1 1-888-667-5151 or www.stewart.ca 2013 top news, newsmakers, and cases 9 11-11-17 4:02 PM

