Law Times - Newsmakers

2013 Top Newsmakers

The premier weekly newspaper for the legal profession in Ontario

Issue link: https://read.uberflip.com/i/223044

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 9 of 15

top stories Spotlight shines on First Nations jury representation on reserves in order to reach out to individuals for jury duty; that it make information on the role of jurors available to First Nations people in their own languages; and that remuneration for jurors be consistent with the cost of living. He also suggested amending the language used in juror questionnaires. The Ministry of the Attorney General committed to acting on the first two recommendations — that the government create an implementation group as well as an advisory committee to oversee the application of the new measures — immediately. In June, the ministry announced the names of the commitBy Mallory HendRy tee members. In a press release, There was big attention this year on the experithe ministry said the committee ence of First Nations in the justice system as would aim for a wide range of a high-profile report and an Ontario Court of perspectives from across the jusAppeal ruling highlighted the need to rectify tice sector and noted it includes the lack of aboriginals on jury rolls. aboriginal leaders, lawyers, curFormer Supreme Court of Canada jusrent and former judges, and tice Frank Iacobucci's report in February policymakers. The two co-chairaddressed the issue of aboriginal represenmen are Nishnawbe Aski Nation tation on juries along with other pressing deputy grand chief Alvin Fiddler matters for First Nations and their relationand assistant deputy attorney ship with the justice system. general Irwin Glasberg. The issue once again took centre stage with At the time, Fiddler said he the Ontario Court of Appeal's June decision to looked forward to working with overturn a 2008 manslaughter conviction in a the ministry in order to ensure case where a jury in Kenora, Ont., convicted implementation of Iacobucci's Clifford Kokopenace of stabbing a friend to recommendations "in a way that death on the Grassy Narrows reserve. truly addresses the crisis of First While the court had upheld the convic- John Gerretsen is confident the implementation committee Nations in the justice system." tion on appeal in 2011, it put the ruling on named this year will make progress on the First Nations "By working together, we are hold as the jury-representation issue garnered jury issue. taking positive steps to ensure recognition and sparked a constitutional chalthat all First Nations can exercise lenge. In June, the appeal court ordered a new trial on the their right to serve on juries and to ensure that there is a path grounds the provincial government, despite knowing about forward to achieving justice for First Nations," said Fiddler. the long-standing problem, had failed to ensure aboriginal Attorney General John Gerretsen was equally confident representation on the jury. that, with the input and advice of the First Nation members, "The integrity of the process was fundamentally comprothe committee "has the right mix of professional expertise and mised by the inattention paid by the state to a known and lived experience to help us find the practical solutions we need worsening problem, year after year," the court stated in R. v. to enhance the representation of First Nation people on juries." Kokopenace. "What the state knew or ought to have known was "I look forward to seeing progress from the committee very considerable; what the state did in response was very little." soon," he said. According to Iacobucci in his report, the issues in KokoAs to the progress the government has made so far, Iacopenance go beyond that case as the plight of aboriginals in bucci says he's "delighted" with the steps it has taken. the legal system is dire. "Today, First Nations peoples see "I went to the first meeting of the implementation comthemselves either as spectators to or victims of the justice mittee and I was very pleased to see the membership that has system, whereas historically they were direct participants in been assembled," says Iacobucci. "There is a majority of memthe resolution of conflict within their own communities," bers of First Nations, two co-chairs — one from First Nations Iacobucci said in the report. and one senior official from government. I was pleased to Among his recommendations, Iacobucci suggested the govsee the progress they have made in terms of a game plan and ernment create a database of First Nations people who live going forward." Report calls for action on the lack of aboriginal members 10 December 2013

Articles in this issue

Archives of this issue

view archives of Law Times - Newsmakers - 2013 Top Newsmakers